Our story

Protecting Families Since 1987

Crestline Insurance Group was founded on a simple belief: every family deserves reliable protection and an agent who truly knows their name.

Our mission

At Crestline, we believe insurance is more than a policy — it's a promise. A promise that when life takes an unexpected turn, you won't face it alone. For nearly four decades, we've helped thousands of families and businesses across the region navigate life's uncertainties with confidence.

We're an independent agency, which means we work for you — not for any single carrier. We shop the market to find coverage that fits your life and your budget, then stand beside you every step of the way.

Get a Free Quote

35+

Years in business

12,000+

Families protected

50+

Carrier partners

98%

Client retention rate

What sets us apart

Independent & unbiased

As an independent agency, we compare dozens of top carriers to find the best coverage at the right price for you.

Local expertise

We know this community because we live here too. Our agents understand the risks and needs specific to our region.

Claims advocacy

When you need to file a claim, we're in your corner — guiding you through the process and advocating on your behalf.

Lifelong relationships

We review your coverage annually to make sure it still fits your life as it grows and changes.

Meet our team

Experienced advisors who put your needs first.

Margaret Holloway

Margaret Holloway

Founder & CEO

With 35 years in the industry, Margaret built Crestline on the principle that every client deserves personal attention and honest advice.

David Chen

David Chen

Senior Insurance Advisor

David specializes in commercial and business insurance, helping local entrepreneurs protect what they've built.

Sarah Okafor

Sarah Okafor

Personal Lines Specialist

Sarah guides families through auto, home, and life insurance decisions with patience and clarity.

Get in touch

Have a question or ready to review your coverage? We'd love to hear from you.

Address

108 W 39th Street Ste 1006 New York, NY 10018

Office hours

Monday – Friday: 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM Saturday: 9:00 AM – 1:00 PM

Need a quote fast?

Use our online quote form and get a response within one business day.

Start Your Quote